Hacking Trial Puts U.K. Press, Politicos, Police On Defense

Oct 27, 2013
Originally published on October 27, 2013 1:10 pm

Journalists who were once among the most powerful in the United Kingdom go on trial in London on Monday. The trial is the result of a 2011 hacking scandal that electrified the media on both sides of the Atlantic and sank Rupert Murdoch's News of the World.

The trial is expected to reveal details of the uncomfortably cozy relationship between the media and political elites, says former Murdoch executive Ken Chandler.

Chandler, who started out as a copy boy on The Sun newspaper in London and rose to be editor and publisher of the New York Post, says those who represented Rupert Murdoch crossed a line.

"You can call me old-fashioned if you like, but I believe that the role of the newspaper is to be a watchdog and to be critical of what the government and politicians are doing," Chandler says. "It's very hard to perform that role if you're socializing the way that they were with the prime minister and other politicians."

The trial itself focuses on charges against prominent former Murdoch journalists, including Rebekah Brooks, the former CEO of his British newspaper arm, and former News of the World editor Andrew Coulson, who went on to be Prime Minister David Cameron's chief PR official.

Last year, Brooks was asked under oath during a judicial inquiry about her frequent text messaging with Cameron.

"Occasionally he would sign them off 'LOL' — lots of love — actually, until I told them it meant 'laugh out loud,' and then he didn't sign them off like that anymore," she said.

Cameron was but one of several prime ministers from both major British parties who curried favor with the Murdoch press over the years. Those politicians shielded the newspapers from tough scrutiny.

In the cell phone hacking scandal, investigators working for newspapers obtained illegal access to private mobile phone voice messages. In the cutthroat British press culture, celebrities and politicians were seen as fair game.

But that all changed in July, 2011, when The Guardian revealed that Murdoch's News of the World had hacked into the cell phone messages of a girl who had been abducted and killed. That led to a public outcry and inspired a police investigation that quickly grew in scope, says George Brock, a former top news executive at Murdoch's The Times of London.

"Don't forget also that phone hacking is now the least of these charges," Brock says. "People are facing charges now of bribing public servants, hacking into other people's computers, and in one case conspiring to conceal evidence from the police."

The conduct of police is also under scrutiny. At a hearing a decade ago, Labour MP Chris Bryant cut to the heart of suspicions while questioning Brooks, then editor-in-chief of The Sun. Bryant asked Brooks whether police were ever paid for information.

"We have paid for the police for information in the past," Brooks answered.

"And will you do it in the future?" Bryant asked.

Andrew Coulson, editor of News of the World, jumped in.

"We operate within the code and within the law," he said. "And if there's a clear public interest, then the same holds for private detectives, for subterfuge, for video bags, whatever you want to talk about."

"It's illegal for police officers to receive payments," Bryant responded.

Bryant was right, it's not legal. Two top officials at Scotland Yard also had to resign after it was disclosed they had frequently received gifts and meals from British News Corp executives.

Prosecutors will seek to prove that Coulson and Brooks were involved in a conspiracy to intercept cell phones, and to prove their involvement in making illegal payments to public officials. All the defendants facing trial this month deny the charges.

Murdoch and News Corp are not commenting, but many British journalists say the police are unfairly compensating for their own failures.

"Because they were so obviously inept and superficial in that first investigation, they have now swung right away to the other side for overkill," Brock says. But, he adds, "the fact is, once you're in that position, the police can't ignore a criminal offense."

As Chandler notes, regardless of the outcome of the trial, British papers are in trouble. Their revenues from circulation and advertising are in decline.

The cost of the legal defense and payments to victims has amounted to hundreds of millions of dollars for News Corp. The cost is likely to grow, and it occurs at a time when British lawmakers, who once praised Murdoch's editors, are now seeking to regulate the press more tightly.

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

RACHEL MARTIN, HOST:

This is WEEKEND EDITION from NPR News. I'm Rachel Martin.

Tomorrow, at a courthouse in London, journalists who once were among the powerful in the United Kingdom will stand trial for conspiracy, concealing evidence and bribery. They were top executives for Rupert Murdoch who owned the now defunct tabloid News of the World.

As NPR's David Folkenflik reports, the trial stems from a 2011 cell phone hacking scandal that electrified media and political circles on both sides of the Atlantic.

DAVID FOLKENFLIK, BYLINE: Former Murdoch executive Ken Chandler started out as a copy boy on the Sun newspaper in London and rose to be editor and publisher of the New York Post. Chandler says the trial will reveal details of the uncomfortably cozy relationship between the political and media elites. Those who represented Rupert Murdoch, he says, crossed a line.

KEN CHANDLER: You can call me old fashioned if you like. But I believe that the role of the newspaper is to be a watchdog, and to be critical of what the government and politicians are doing. And it's very hard to perform that role if you're socializing the way that they were with the prime minister and other politicians.

FOLKENFLIK: The trial itself focuses on charges against prominent former Murdoch journalists including Rebekah Brooks, the former CEO of his British newspaper arm, and the former News of the World editor Andrew Coulson, who went on to be Prime Minister Cameron's chief PR official.

Last year Brooks was asked under oath during a judicial inquiry about her frequent text messages with prime minister.

REBEKAH BROOKS: Occasionally he would sign them off LOL - lots of love - actually until I told them it meant laugh out loud. And then he didn't sign them off like that anymore.

FOLKENFLIK: Cameron was but one of several prime ministers from both major British parties who curried favor with the Murdoch press over the years. And those politicians shielded the newspapers from tough scrutiny. Cell phone hacking provides a clear example. Investigators working for newspapers obtained illegal access to private mobile phone voice messages. In the cutthroat British press culture, celebrities and politicians were seen as fair game.

But that all changed in July 2011 when The Guardian revealed that Murdoch's News of the World had hacked into the cell phone messages of a girl who had been abducted and killed. That led to a public outcry. And as George Brock notes, it inspired a police investigation that quickly grew in scope. Brock is a former top news executive at Murdoch's Times of London.

GEORGE BROCK: Don't forget also that phone hacking is now the least of these charges. People are facing now charges of bribing public servants, hacking into other people's computers and in one case, conspiring to conceal evidence from police.

FOLKENFLIK: The conduct of police is also under scrutiny. At a hearing a decade ago, Labour MP Chris Bryant cut to the heart of suspicions while questioning Brooks - then editor-in-chief of the Sun -

CHRIS BRYANT: Just the one element of whether you ever paid the police for information.

BROOKS: Yeah, we have paid for the police and for information in the past. And it's been...

BRYANT: And will you do it in the future?

FOLKENFLIK: Andrew Coulson, editor of News of the World, jumped in.

ANDREW COULSON: We operate within the code and within the law. And if there's a clear public interest, then the same holds for private detectives for subterfuge, for video bags, whatever you want to talk about.

BRYANT: It's illegal for police officers to receive payments.

FOLKENFLIK: That last voice belonged to Chris Bryant. And the British MP was right, it's not legal. Two top officials at Scotland Yard also had to resign after it was disclosed they had frequently received gifts and meals from British News Corp executives.

Prosecutors will seek to prove that Coulson and Brooks were involved in a conspiracy to intercept cell phones, and to prove their involvement in making illegal payments to public officials. All the defendants facing trial this month deny the charges. Murdoch and News Corp are not commenting, but many British journalists say the police are unfairly compensating for their own failures.

Again, George Brock.

BROCK: Because they were so obviously inept and superficial in that first investigation, they have now swung right away to the other side for overkill. The fact is that once you're in that position, the police cannot ignore a criminal offense.

FOLKENFLIK: The cost of the legal defense and payments to victims have amounted to hundreds of millions of dollars for News Corp. The cost is likely to grow. And it occurs at a time British lawmakers, who once praised Murdoch's editors, are now seeking to regulate the press more tightly.

David Folkenflik, NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.