How A County Clerk Ignited The Gay Marriage Debate In N.M.

Oct 22, 2013
Originally published on October 23, 2013 11:51 am

New Mexico law doesn't explicitly ban or approve same-sex marriage. There were a spate of lawsuits seeking to clarify the issue, but they were tied up in the courts. Then in August, the clerk of Dona Ana County, Lynn Ellins, a long-time supporter of same-sex marriage, consulted his staff.

"And we all agreed that it was about time to bring this thing to a head, and if we did nothing, the cases would languish in the district court if we did not move to issue these licenses and try and put the ball in play," Ellins says.

Soon state judges ordered four other county clerks to follow Ellins' lead and together they have issued more than 900 marriage licenses. But not every county clerk was prepared to do the same in their communities. Instead, all 33 county clerks in New Mexico agreed to petition the state Supreme Court for a final say on the matter. The main opposition comes from a group of Republican lawmakers led by state Sen. William Sharer of Farmington.

"So when Lynn Ellins decided that he was the only one in New Mexico that could properly read the law and declared that same-sex marriage was legal, I stepped in and said, 'No, you're wrong. We must stop this,' Sharer says, adding that Ellins "far exceeded his authority."

But the reaction from other quarters has been relatively mild. New Mexico's three Catholic bishops said the action of the county clerks should be resolved by the Legislature. And Republican Gov. Susana Martinez has said the issue should be determined by the voters.

But supporters of same-sex marriage say local polls indicate that New Mexicans are prepared to accept a state Supreme Court ruling confirming marriage equality. They are also encouraged by what's happened in New Jersey, says Elizabeth Gill of the ACLU.

"It's yet another court that has analyzed whether there's any real reason to discriminate against same-sex couples in marriage and concluded that there is not," she says.

Gill and others say their side has momentum.

  • In Oregon last week, state authorities said they would recognize same-sex marriages performed in other states. Advocates are trying to get a freedom-to-marry initiative on Oregon's ballot in November 2014.
  • In Illinois, a same-sex marriage bill awaits action by the lower House.
  • In Pennsylvania, a federal lawsuit challenging that state's same-sex marriage ban is in the courts, and there's a marriage equality bill before the Legislature.
  • In Hawaii, a special legislative session has been called for later this month to consider a marriage bill.
  • And in Tennessee, there's a lawsuit challenging both state law and a constitutional amendment banning same-sex marriage.

Sara Warbelow, a spokeswoman for the D.C.-based Human Rights Campaign, says in some states it appears marriage equality is inevitable.

"There's been a fair amount of polling, and rather consistently, 80 percent of the American public says within the next 10 years, marriage equality will be the law of the land," Warbelow says.

Back in New Mexico, the Supreme Court justices have taken the unusual step of expanding oral arguments Wednesday from 20 minutes to one hour for each side. They have not indicated when they will issue their decision. In the meantime the court is allowing marriages to continue.

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

MELISSA BLOCK, HOST:

The movement for marriage equality for gay and lesbian couples appears to be gaining momentum. Same-sex couples began marrying yesterday in New Jersey after the state's Supreme Court refused to intervene. Next up is New Mexico. As NPR's Richard Gonzales reports, that state's Supreme Court will consider the constitutionality of same-sex marriage tomorrow.

RICHARD GONZALES, BYLINE: Ona Porter and Miriam Rand of Albuquerque have been together since 1988. It was long enough ago, as Ona puts it, when...

ONA PORTER: It was not OK to be lesbians raising kids.

GONZALES: In fact, they blended their families and raised three daughters together. They persisted even when other family members turned their backs on them. And they've rallied to support a daughter and granddaughter who have debilitating illnesses, says Miriam.

MIRIAM RAND: On that kind of level, we have committed to one another now for over 25 years.

GONZALES: Yet they were only able to tie the knot last month, thanks to an unusual turn of events. New Mexico law doesn't explicitly ban or approve same-sex marriage. There were a spate of lawsuits seeking to clarify the issue, but they were tied up in the courts. Then in August, the clerk of Dona Ana County, Lynn Ellins, a long time supporter of same-sex marriage, consulted his staff.

LYNN ELLINS: And we all agreed that it was about time to bring this thing to a head. And if we did nothing, the cases would languish in the district court if we did not move and issue these licenses and try and put the ball in play.

GONZALES: Soon state judges ordered four other county clerks to follow Ellins' lead, and together they have issued more than 900 marriage licenses. But not every county clerk was prepared to do the same in their communities. Instead, all 33 county clerks in New Mexico agreed to petition the State Supreme Court for a final say on the matter. The main opposition comes from a group of Republican lawmakers led by State Senator William Sharer of Farmington.

STATE SENATOR WILLIAM SHARER: So when Lynn Ellins decided that he was the only one in New Mexico that could properly read the law and declared that same-sex marriage was legal, I stepped in and said: No, you're wrong - we must stop this.

GONZALES: So you're essentially saying that he exceeded his authority.

SHARER: He far exceeded his authority.

GONZALES: But the reaction from other quarters has been relatively mild. New Mexico's three Catholic bishops said the action of the county clerks should be resolved by the legislature. And the Republican Governor Susanna Martinez has said the issue should be determined by the voters.

But supporters of same-sex marriage say local polls indicate that New Mexicans are prepared to accept a State Supreme Court ruling confirming marriage equality. They are also encouraged by what's happened in New Jersey, says Elizabeth Gill of the ACLU.

ELIZABETH GILL: It's yet another court that has analyzed whether there is any real reason to discriminate against same-sex couples in marriage and concluded that there is not.

GONZALES: Gil and others say their side has momentum. In Oregon last week, state authorities said they would recognize same-sex marriages performed in other states. Advocates are trying to get a Freedom to Marry Initiative on Oregon's ballot in November 2014. In Illinois, a same-sex marriage bill awaits action by the Lower House. In Pennsylvania, a federal lawsuit challenging that state's same-sex marriage ban is in the courts, and there's a marriage equality bill in the legislature. In Hawaii, a special legislative session has been called for later this month to consider a marriage bill. And in Tennessee, there's a lawsuit challenging both state law and a constitutional amendment banning same-sex marriage.

Sara Warbelow is a spokeswoman for the D.C.-based Human Rights Campaign. She says, in some states, it appears marriage equality is inevitable.

SARA WARBELOW: There's been a fair amount of polling and rather consistently 80 percent of the American public says within the next 10 years marriage equality will be the law of the land.

GONZALES: Back in New Mexico, the Supreme Court justices have taken the unusual step of expanding oral arguments tomorrow from 20 minutes to one hour for each side. They have not indicated when they will issue their decision. In the meantime, the court is allowing marriages to continue.

Richard Gonzales, NPR News.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

AUDIE CORNISH, HOST:

You're listening to ALL THINGS CONSIDERED from NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.