Latina Gov. A Rising Star, Just Not To Some Hispanics

Mar 29, 2012
Originally published on March 29, 2012 9:25 am

New Mexico Gov. Susana Martinez is the ultimate immigrant success story: Two generations after her Mexican grandparents arrived in the U.S., she became the nation's first Latina governor.

And with an overall approval rating of 66 percent of New Mexicans after more than a year in office, she is arguably the most popular Republican governor in the country.

But that popularity doesn't always translate among Hispanics, a group that in New Mexico makes up nearly half of the population.

One issue that makes many of the state's Latino voters seethe is their governor's stance on driver's licenses and illegal immigrants. In her 2010 campaign, Martinez promised to repeal a law that makes New Mexico one of only three states in the country where illegal immigrants can get a driver's license.

At a speech in Albuquerque last year, Martinez said getting rid of the law is a matter of public safety.

"We have thousands of individuals who come to our state from not just Mexico, but all over the world in order to gain that very valuable ID," she said.

A bill to repeal the driver's license law has failed three times in the state legislature, and some critics charge that Martinez's support of that bill is really part of a long-term political strategy.

"Why she is introducing policies that are divisive to the Latino community, we could only guess that it's for political gain," says Adrian Pedroza, who works with Hispanic neighborhoods in Albuquerque as the director of a local nonprofit.

'Well, I'll Be. I'm A Republican.'

Martinez, 52, is often touted as a possible 2012 Republican vice presidential nominee, although she has said she would decline any offer.

Martinez grew up in a family of Democrats in a bilingual household in El Paso, Texas, just blocks from the border with Mexico. At 18, she worked in her father's business as a revolver-carrying security guard outside a bingo hall.

She graduated from law school and later considered entering politics. That's when some Republican friends took her out to dinner. It's a story she often shares publicly.

"We talked about values; we talked about where we stood in reference to how the economy was going; we talked about welfare as being a hand up and not a way of life; we talked about the freedoms, the Second Amendment," she says. "And I remember walking out of there and getting in the car with my husband, Chuck, and saying, 'Well, I'll be. I'm a Republican.' "

Shortly after that, she ran for and was elected district attorney in the southern New Mexico county of Dona Ana.

Bringing In Latino Voters

New Mexico is considered a swing state that tends to lean in favor of Democrats, but the February Rasmussen poll shows Martinez enjoys broad support, even among Democrats, with whom her approval rating tops 50 percent. Among Hispanics in the state, 58 percent approve of the job she is doing, but 33 percent noted they "strongly disapprove" of her job performance — the highest of any group polled.

"I think because she is a Hispanic woman, she gets criticized more," says Cindy Retana, an El Paso school principal and Martinez's younger cousin. Retana says Martinez is being singled out for criticism because of her ethnic background. "She's seen as forgetting where you come from, not being supportive of immigrants, which is absolutely the farthest thing from the truth."

Martinez has said she is proud of her Mexican heritage, but she rarely speaks of her experience as a Latina. She faces the same burning question as other high-profile Hispanic Republicans, like Nevada Gov. Brian Sandoval and Florida Sen. Marco Rubio: Can she make the party more appealing to Latino voters nationwide?

That remains to be seen, but what is certain is that the GOP faces an uphill battle. Another February poll of likely Hispanic voters nationwide, conducted by Fox News Latino, shows President Obama leading either Mitt Romney or Rick Santorum by about a five-to-one margin in a prospective matchup.

The same poll found that 18 percent of respondents said they would be more likely to vote for the Republican nominee if Martinez was the vice presidential choice. When Rubio was the vice presidential candidate, that number jumped to 24 percent.

Copyright 2013 KJZZ-FM. To see more, visit http://kjzz.org/.

Transcript

RENEE MONTAGNE, HOST:

Let's turn to the governor of New Mexico who is considered the ultimate immigrant success story. Two generations after her Mexican grandparents arrived in the United States, Susana Martinez became the nation's first Latina governor. And with an overall approval rating of 66 percent, she's arguably the most popular Republican governor in the country. Still, that popularity does not translate to support from many Hispanics.

From member station KJZZ, Monica Ortiz Uribe reports

MONICA ORTIZ URIBE, BYLINE: Nearly half the population in New Mexico is Hispanic, and one issue that makes many Latino voters here seethe, is their governor's stance on driver's licenses and illegal immigrants.

(SOUNDBITE OF COMMERCIAL)

GOVERNOR SUSANA MARTINEZ: Criminals take advantage of weak laws by getting driver's licenses to illegal immigrants. As governor, that will change.

URIBE: Governor Susana Martinez campaigned on the issue, promising to repeal a law that makes New Mexico one of only three states in the country where illegal immigrants can get a driver's license. At a speech in Albuquerque last year, Martinez said getting rid of the law is a matter of public safety.

MARTINEZ: We have thousands of individuals who come to our state, from not just Mexico, but all over the world in order to gain that very valuable ID.

URIBE: A bill to repeal the driver's license law has failed three times in the state legislature. Critics suspect Martinez's support of that bill is part of a long-term political strategy. Adrian Pedroza works with Hispanic neighborhoods in Albuquerque as the director of a local nonprofit.

ADRIAN PEDROZA: Why she's introducing policies that are divisive to the Latino community, we could only guess that it's for political gain.

URIBE: Martinez is often touted as a possible Republican vice presidential nominee, an offer she's said she'd decline. See, Martinez is a rare gem in the Republican Party. She grew up in a family of Democrats, in a bilingual household just blocks from the border with Mexico. At 18, she worked in her father's business as a security guard, carrying a revolver outside a bingo hall.

She graduated law school and later considered entering politics. That's when some Republican friends took her out to dinner. It's a story she often shares publicly.

MARTINEZ: We talked about values; we talked about where we stood in reference to how the economy was going; we talked about welfare as being a hand up and not a way of life; we talked about the freedoms, the Second Amendment. And I remember walking out of there and getting in the car with my husband, Chuck, and saying: well, I'll be, I'm a Republican.

Shortly after that, she ran for and was elected district attorney in the southern county of Dona Ana. New Mexico is considered a swing state that tends to lean in favor of Democrats, but a recent poll shows Martinez enjoys a two-thirds approval rating. Hispanics, on the other hand, approve of the governor by only one-third.

CINDY RETANA: I think because she is a Hispanic woman, she gets criticized more.

URIBE: Cindy Retana is a school principal in El Paso and is a younger cousin of Martinez's. She says Martinez is being singled out for criticism because of her ethnic background.

RETANA: She's seen as forgetting where you come from, not being supportive of immigrants, which is absolutely the farthest thing from the truth.

URIBE: Martinez has said she is proud of her Mexican heritage, but rarely speaks about her experience as a Latina. She faces the same burning question as other high-profile Hispanic Republicans, like Nevada Governor Brian Sandoval and Florida Senator Marco Rubio: Can she make the party more appealing to Latino voters, nationally?

What is certain is that the GOP faces an uphill battle. A recent poll of Hispanic voters by Fox News Latino, shows President Obama leading all Republican candidates by five-to-one.

For NPR News, I'm Monica Ortiz Uribe.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

MONTAGNE: You're listening to MORNING EDITION from NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.